interesting appropriate final keyword descriptive student wa teach administrated learning research get approach valid ABSTRACT four nainggolan narrative uninteresting data instrument evaluation develop 2123321017 method material information procedure into good state textbook make improvement aspect creative product design university 100 ha based thesi scientific use aim pop lectrurer result text need validated collecting medan 2019 development grade significant designed they SMA validation language analyzed media questionnaire subject study about english art said second skill technique teacher very teaching swasta analysi book expert questionnare using destriwanty bored faculty raksana used developing step found reading while didn tenth innovative modified existing first