taken classe type share there rejected taught think 666 aimed TYPEAND keyword THINK student wa collecting learning medan research essay all 4133311020 tcalculated mathematic higher homogeneity ABSTRACT who BASED homogeneou SMATHEMATICAL TPS alternative normality model classroom OFSTUDENT score normal suggested sampling clas random accepted end than sirait data difference ttable quasi communication mathematical two each PBL technique consequently find posttest average iii experiment teacher sample ID problem then analyzing sarah given analysi ability BY SHARE cooperative using significance COMMUNICATION obtained concluded COOPERATIVE variance level done H0 experimental II consisted population test USING PAIR distribution improving ha based budi THEDIFFERENCE either LEARNING out consist violita PROBLEM use SMP murni VIII ABILITY pair hypothesi