taken classe show deal table keyword substantial descriptive student wa research significantly academic higher ABSTRACT affected 2015 calculation pre 2014 score implie sampling group reliable than without department data after perguruan novandhy semester into state finding significance university divided population test ha reliability thesi degree showed achievement observed mean effect there selected applying taught coefficient text medan total control grade significant IPS post they SMA language analyzed indonesia study together english art random membangun two technique year sample 2103321047 teaching formula analyzing swasta indicate numbered tri using namely freedom level faculty experimental used yayasan reading while silaen head first