interview ran descriptive student wa learning research significantly estate ABSTRACT sheet four qualitative action diary classroom 2014 score kept department enthusiastic data quantitative interested IX instrument evaluation method state improve university well nim attempted test improving especially based thesi showed TGT achievement SMP mean note meeting result text collecting medan desi cycle language yusnanda subject every study observation improved english art clas active tournament second conducted two 209321039 III teaching proces using comprehension PAB faculty II consisted sari found game reading through team first